No one gets possession of James' soul unless the former commadore says so. Davey Jones didn't get to have it and Erlking certainly doesn't get to keep it. Now do what the very ticked off Goblin King says and hand it over.
(Love the BAMF comment mayaegyptkezi!) You are amazing at doing these costumes! I feel bad because I'm SUPER crushing on Jareth right now, and I'm a super Sarah/Jareth shipper too! (Go Jareth, You Bamf!)