The first round of dates:
Elphaba from Wicked, Kira from The Dark Crystal, and random Tortuga "lady of the night". See Jamie's rather drunken explanation.
Erik belongs to Leroux and Webber.
Jareth belongs to Henson, Lucas, and Bowie.
Norrington belongs to Disney, Bruckheimer, and Davenport.
Javert belongs to Hugo, Boublil, Schonberg, and Kretzmer.
Elphaba belongs to Maguire.
Kira belongs to Henson, Odell, and Oz.